Your MCP Server Must Refuse That Token
· 15 min read

You are wrapping a third-party API in an MCP server. The client that connects to you already holds an access token for that API, and it sends the token along. Your server has the token, the API wants the token, and there is a perfectly good Authorization header sitting right there.
Forward it. Ship it. Move on.
The MCP specification says otherwise, in the flattest language it uses anywhere: MCP servers MUST NOT accept any tokens that were not explicitly issued for the MCP server. Most of the security guidance in MCP is a SHOULD. This one is a MUST NOT, and it is worth understanding why the bar is set that high.